In New South Wales, executors are often placed in the position of defending family provision claims brought under the Succession Act 2006 (NSW). These claims arise when an eligible person alleges that the deceased’s will, or the distribution of the estate on intestacy, fails to make adequate provision for their proper maintenance, education, or advancement in life. The role of the executor in such proceedings is both complex and critical, requiring a careful balance between upholding the deceased’s testamentary intentions and complying with statutory obligations.
Legal Framework and Eligibility
The Succession Act 2006 (NSW) sets out the categories of persons eligible to make a family provision claim, including spouses, de facto partners, children, former spouses, and certain dependants. The Court, upon application, has the discretion to order that provision be made out of the estate for the applicant if it is satisfied that adequate provision has not been made.
Executor’s Duties and Defending the Claim
The executor’s primary duty is to administer the estate in accordance with the will and the law. When a family provision claim is lodged, the executor must act impartially, representing the interests of all beneficiaries and the estate as a whole. The executor is not to act as an adversary to the claimant, but rather as a neutral party providing the Court with all relevant information to enable a just determination.
In defending a claim, the executor is required to:
- Disclose Full Estate Details: Provide the Court with a comprehensive account of the estate’s assets and liabilities, including valuations and any relevant financial documentation.
- Outline Beneficiaries’ Circumstances: Present evidence regarding the financial and personal circumstances of all beneficiaries and the claimant, including their needs, resources, and relationship with the deceased.
- Highlight Competing Claims: Identify and explain any competing claims on the estate, such as those of other eligible persons or creditors.
- Uphold the Deceased’s Intentions: Where possible, articulate the rationale behind the deceased’s testamentary dispositions, including any statements of wishes or explanations for the distribution made.
Defence Strategies
The executor may defend the claim on several bases, including:
- Adequacy of Provision: Arguing that the provision made for the claimant (if any) is adequate for their proper maintenance, education, and advancement in life.
- Lack of Eligibility: Contesting the claimant’s eligibility under the Act.
- Absence of Need: Demonstrating that the claimant does not have financial need warranting further provision.
- Competing Interests: Emphasising the legitimate claims and needs of other beneficiaries, which may outweigh those of the claimant.
Court’s Role and Executor’s Protection
The Court will weigh all relevant factors, including the size of the estate, the nature of the relationships involved, and the financial circumstances of all parties. Executors should seek directions from the Court where there is uncertainty or potential conflict, and may apply for orders protecting them from personal liability for costs incurred in defending the claim, provided they have acted reasonably and in good faith.
Conclusion
Defending a family provision claim in New South Wales requires executors to act diligently, impartially, and transparently. By fulfilling their statutory and fiduciary duties, executors assist the Court in achieving a fair outcome that balances the interests of all parties and upholds the integrity of the estate administration process.
The information in this publication is of a general nature and is not intended to address the circumstances of any particular individual or entity. Although we endeavour to provide accurate and timely information, we do not guarantee that the information in this publication is accurate at the date it is received or that it will continue to be accurate in the future. We are not responsible for the information of any source to which a link is provided or reference is made and exclude all liability in connection with use of these sources. If you do not wish to receive newsletters from us, please let us know.