How does a Court interpret a contract?

Apr 20, 2023 | Publication

The interpretation or ‘construction’ of contracts is a sub-set of contract law.

In Australia, when interpreting a contract, Courts will attempt to give effect to what the parties intended.  What the parties intended is to be assessed objectively not subjectively.

What a commercial contract means is to be determined by what a reasonable business person would understand those terms to mean.

The starting point is the words actually used.  The Court will give express terms their plain and ordinary meaning unless doing so would result in manifest absurdity.  Australian dictionaries generally should be used rather than English dictionaries in determining the plain and ordinary meaning of words.

If a term of a contract is ambiguous or capable of more than one meaning, the court will attempt to give the contract a businesslike and commercial interpretation.

Some common words and phrases which commonly appear in contracts (e.g. “use all reasonable endeavours”) have been decided by the courts and have obtained a legally accepted meaning as a result.

The “parole evidence rule” means that evidence of prior negotiations is not admissible to the interpretation of contract terms unless it provides evidence of the surrounding circumstances.  Such evidence is admissible but not in aid of a subjective interpretation of the problem clause.

Latest Insights

Partnership Disputes – Causes and Resolution

Partnerships are a common business structure.  Frequently we see disputes where one or more partners wishes to leave the partnership, and financial and other disputes relating to a partnership.  Understanding the causes of these disputes and how they can be...

What Types of Claims can be made on a Deceased Estate?

A deceased estate has a range of potential claims that can be made against it.  These arise not only from the actions of the deceased but also from legislation that deals with how deceased estates are administered and distributed. Some examples of potential...

Fundamentals of Companies – Getting the Basics Right

A company is a separate legal entity, being an artificial person that only ceases to exist via the hands of its members or via government intervention.  A company’s personality is expressed in its constitution and enables the members of the company to combine...

Loss of chance

In the landmark decision of Tabet v Gett [2010] 240 CLR 537, the High Court of Australia provided crucial insights into the principles of causation in negligence claims. This case is pivotal for understanding how courts assess the direct link between alleged...

Webinar – How to Reduce the Risk of a Claim on Your Estate

Join us for an informative seminar on "How to Reduce the Risk of a Claim on Your Estate" via Zoom on Thursday, 5 September at 8 pm. This one-hour complimentary session, including a Q&A segment, will provide valuable insights and practical strategies to safeguard...

New Industrial Manslaughter laws in NSW

The Industrial Manslaughter Bill has passed NSW Parliament and will make industrial manslaugther an offence. According to the NSW government, since 2019 more than 300 workers have been killed in NSW.  Under the new law, a business or individual can be held...

8 Types of People that can Claim on a Deceased Estate

In New South Wales, there are many different types of people that can potentially claim on a deceased estate if, for instance, inadequate or no provision has been made for them or they are owed money by the estate (or they were owed money by the deceased).  ...

What is the difference between Joint Tenancy and Tenants in Common?

A very important difference in ownership of property where there are two or more owners is Joint Tenancy v Tenants in Common. It is essential to understand the difference when and if you buy property with another person. If you own a property as Joint Tenants and one...