Lawyers, judges want more courtrooms out west

Mar 31, 2023 | Publication

The legal fraternity has called for a major expansion of court infrastructure in western Sydney to meet the growing number of civil, commercial, and criminal cases.

The arrival of the four big accounting firms – PwC, Deloitte, KPMG and EY – in Parramatta has driven an upswing in civil and commercial matters, says local solicitor Stephen McAuley.

At the same time, the area’s highly multi-ethnic population, which has grown by 5 per cent in the past five years and is forecast to surge by nearly 10 per cent by 2028, is generating a large pipeline of work.

“It’s not just about convenience for the legal fraternity, it’s about servicing the community,” McAuley says.

“You currently have litigants and witnesses trekking from the Blue Mountains, Penrith and Liverpool into Sydney’s CBD to appear in Supreme Court matters,” he says.

The chief justice of NSW, Andrew Bell, is also pushing for more courtrooms to be built throughout the greater Sydney area, including in south-west Sydney, to match population growth.

Population increase means rising legal needs, says solicitor Stephen McAuley.  

It might not be “a vote-winner” but modern and adequate courtrooms are “an essential part of our civic and civil infrastructure”, Bell said during a visit to Parramatta last month.

“The surging diversity and depth of fresh talent originating from and residing in western Sydney is obvious,” he said.

The freshly ousted NSW Liberal and Nationals government claims “record investments in courts’ infrastructure” during its term.

NSW Attorney-General Mark Speakman points to almost $4 million worth of audio-visual technology upgrades over four years in court facilities in Parramatta – 16 per cent of its total budget for AV upgrades.

Speakman says the new $2.3 million NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal has quadrupled capacity in Parramatta to over 17,000 hearings a year.

But top local law firms, universities and business groups say the 25,000 matters heard in Parramatta across the Local, District and Supreme Courts could be doubled.

They also want the Supreme Court to establish a physical presence in Parramatta, like it has in King Street in the CBD and Taylor Square, Darlinghurst, so an additional 30 per cent of Supreme Court hearings can take place there.

According to a council report, this would create an extra 2200 legal jobs and inject as much as $350 million into the local economy.

Law Society of NSW president Cassandra Banks says a debate on whether more Justices ought to be assigned permanently to any region of NSW, including Parramatta, would be welcome.

The Supreme Court has increased its activities in western Sydney in recent years. Some of the most significant terrorism trials have been heard in Parramatta and two of its judges regularly sit in the precinct. But locals argue it is not frequent enough for the caseload the region is producing and carrying. And it does not cover a broad enough spectrum of the law.

There is capacity for an extra 4000 Supreme Court matters to be heard in Parramatta each year, the council report states.

Latest Insights

The Rise of Generative AI in Law and the Need for Caution

Generative artificial intelligence (Gen AI), a subset of artificial intelligence focused on creating new content, has gained significant traction in various industries, including law. Capable of producing text, images, and audio, platforms like ChatGPT are among the...

Australia Introduces Statutory Tort for Serious Invasions of Privacy

The Australian legal landscape is about to undergo a significant transformation with the introduction of a statutory tort for serious invasions of privacy. This change comes with the passage of the Privacy and Other Legislation Amendment Bill 2024 by the Commonwealth...

Building Disputes – Which Court or Tribunal Deals with Them?

In New South Wales, there are different forums to have building disputes and claims addressed. The NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal handles building disputes particularly residential building work claims.  There are numerous claims prosecuted and defended in...

When should a business take legal action on an overdue account?

Generally speaking, an overdue account should be acted on promptly.  The longer it is left, the greater the likelihood the account will need to be written off. Unless the debtor has a satisfactory reason for delaying payment, the account should be followed...

Court Rules Against Kmart in Personal Injury Appeal

In a recent case, Kmart has been held liable for injuries sustained by a customer in its Woy Woy store, after a mountain bike in a heavy, oversized box fell from another customer's shopping trolley, injuring Ms Rita Marmara. The New South Wales Court of Appeal upheld...

Can a Shareholder claim against a Company?

A shareholder can claim against a company under some circumstances. Shareholders have specific rights and interests in a company, and there are scenarios where they might have grounds to make a claim. Some common situations include: Breach of Shareholder Agreement: If...

Court of Appeal Clarifies GP’s Duty of Care in Varipatis v Almario

In a landmark decision, the New South Wales Court of Appeal upheld the appeal of a general practitioner (GP) who was previously found negligent for not referring a morbidly obese patient for bariatric surgery. The case, Varipatis v Almario [2013] NSWCA 76, provides...