In Morgan v Mid North Coast Local Health District and Gayed [2026] NSWDC 386, the District Court of New South Wales considered an application under s 62A of the Limitation Act 1969 (NSW) to extend the 12-year long-stop limitation period applicable to personal injury claims under s 50C(1)(b) of the Act.
The plaintiff, Mrs Joanne Morgan, sought an extension in respect of her claim against the second defendant, Dr Emil Gayed, arising from allegations of negligence and trespass in connection with medical treatment and advice that allegedly caused her injury.
An application for a similar extension in respect of the first defendant, Mid North Coast Local Health District, was no longer in issue following consent orders made on 22 December 2025, entering judgment for the first defendant with no order as to costs.
The decision provides useful guidance on the circumstances in which the Court may exercise its discretion to extend the long-stop limitation period, particularly where a plaintiff could not reasonably have discovered the potential cause of action within the statutory period.
The Legislative Framework
Section 50C of the Limitation Act 1969 (NSW) provides that a personal injury action is not maintainable if commenced after the expiry of whichever of the following periods occurs first:
• The three-year limitation period commencing when the cause of action is discoverable; or
• The 12-year long-stop limitation period commencing from the date of the relevant act or omission.
As confirmed in Vonhoff v Hillier [2024] NSWSC, the expiry of either applicable limitation period may operate as a bar to proceedings.
However, ss 62A and 62B of the Act confer power on the Court to extend the long-stop limitation period where the statutory requirements are satisfied and the Court considers an extension to be just and reasonable.
The provisions recognise that the operation of a long-stop limitation period may, in certain circumstances, produce an unjust result, particularly where a plaintiff could not reasonably have discovered the relevant cause of action within the prescribed period.
The Issues Before the Court
The principal issues for determination were:
1. Whether the plaintiff’s cause of action was discoverable only after the expiry of the 12-year long-stop limitation period.
2. Whether it was just and reasonable to extend the long-stop limitation period pursuant to s 62A.
3. Whether granting an extension would cause prejudice to the second defendant, including any forensic prejudice arising from the passage of time.
The Court’s Findings
Discoverability
The Court determined that the plaintiff’s cause of action became discoverable on 11 July 2024.
Accordingly, the plaintiff had not acquired the requisite knowledge to appreciate that she might have a compensable cause of action until after the 12-year long-stop period had effectively expired.
The significance of this finding was that the plaintiff had been unable to commence proceedings within the long-stop period, notwithstanding that she had not previously possessed the knowledge necessary to appreciate the potential basis of her claim.
Whether an Extension Was Just and Reasonable
In considering the relevant statutory factors under ss 62A and 62B (at [159]–[180]), the Court examined the plaintiff’s circumstances, the apparent merits of the claim and the potential prejudice to the second defendant.
The matters favouring an extension included:
• The plaintiff had acted reasonably once her cause of action became discoverable.
• There was no significant or unexplained delay in pursuing the claim after discoverability.
• The claim appeared to have sufficient merit to justify permitting the proceedings to continue.
• Much of the relevant medical evidence remained available.
• Any prejudice to Dr Gayed arising from the passage of time was not sufficient to outweigh the injustice to the plaintiff if she were prevented from pursuing her claim.
• The plaintiff’s lack of earlier knowledge of the potential claim was a significant consideration favouring an extension.
The Court’s assessment required a consideration of the competing interests of the parties, including the prejudice that might arise from permitting litigation to proceed after the expiry of the statutory long-stop period.
Ultimately, the Court was satisfied that the circumstances justified the exercise of its discretion in the plaintiff’s favour.
Outcome
The Court granted the application under s 62A and extended the 12-year long-stop limitation period to 24 July 2024 in respect of the proceedings against Dr Gayed.
As a result, the plaintiff’s claim against the second defendant was no longer barred by the expiry of the ordinary long-stop limitation period and could proceed.
Significance for Medical Negligence Claims
The decision is a useful reminder that the 12-year long-stop limitation period under s 50C of the Limitation Act 1969 (NSW), while an important statutory restriction, is not necessarily an absolute bar in every case.
In particular, Morgan demonstrates that:
• An extension may be available: Section 62A provides the Court with a discretionary power to extend the long-stop period where the statutory requirements are satisfied.
• Discoverability is critical: The circumstances in which a plaintiff first acquires knowledge of a potential compensable cause of action may be central to an application for an extension.
• The plaintiff’s conduct matters: The Court will consider whether the plaintiff acted reasonably and pursued the claim without significant unexplained delay once the cause of action became discoverable.
• Forensic prejudice must be assessed: The availability of medical records, witnesses and other relevant evidence will be important when considering the prejudice that an extension may cause a defendant.
• The interests of justice remain relevant: The Court must weigh the potential prejudice to the defendant against the injustice that may result if the plaintiff is denied the opportunity to pursue an otherwise viable claim.
For plaintiffs pursuing medical negligence claims, the decision highlights the importance of carefully examining when a potential cause of action became discoverable, particularly where the relevant medical treatment occurred many years earlier. It also demonstrates that the expiry of the 12-year long-stop period should not necessarily be treated as the end of the matter without first considering whether an extension under s 62A may be available. At McAuley Lawyers, we understand the importance of limitation periods in medical negligence claims. If you believe you have suffered injury as a result of negligent medical treatment, obtaining legal advice promptly is essential, particularly where the treatment occurred some years ago.
The information in this publication is of a general nature and is not intended to address the circumstances of any particular individual or entity. Although we endeavour to provide accurate and timely information, we do not guarantee that the information in this publication is accurate at the date it is received or that it will continue to be accurate in the future. We are not responsible for the information of any source to which a link is provided or reference is made and exclude all liability in connection with use of these sources. If you do not wish to receive newsletters from us, please let us know.