Section 23 of the Civil Liability Act: Facilitating Structured Settlements

Jun 18, 2024 | Publication

In the realm of civil litigation concerning personal injury damages, Section 23 of the Civil Liability Act plays a crucial role in ensuring transparency and opportunity for negotiation in the process of awarding damages, particularly for future losses exceeding $100,000. This provision mandates that before a court finalises its decision on such awards, it must inform all parties involved about the proposed terms of the award.

Purpose and Scope

The primary objective of Section 23 is to afford the parties in legal proceedings a reasonable opportunity to negotiate what is known as a structured settlement. Unlike lump-sum payments, structured settlements involve payouts over time, often tailored to the specific needs of the injured party. This approach can provide financial security and stability, especially for those who have suffered significant injuries requiring ongoing care or support.

Notification Requirements

Section 23(2) stipulates that if the court intends to award personal injury damages for future loss exceeding $100,000 (excluding interest), it must first notify all parties of the proposed terms of the award. This notification is pivotal as it allows the parties to fully comprehend the basis and implications of the court’s decision and to prepare their responses accordingly.

Furthermore, Section 23(3) mandates that if the court identifies a party who may be considered a “person in need of protection,” it must notify the NSW Trustee & Guardian of the proposed award terms. According to Section 23(5), a “person in need of protection” is someone who may require legal intervention due to incapacity to manage their own affairs, as defined under the NSW Trustee and Guardian Act 2009.

Detailed Disclosure

The notification required under Section 23(4) must include a breakdown of each component part of the proposed award, adhering to the specific requirements outlined in relevant regulations and court rules. This level of detail ensures transparency and facilitates informed decision-making among the parties involved.

Implications for Negotiation

By providing advance notice of the proposed award, Section 23 empowers parties to engage in meaningful negotiations aimed at reaching a structured settlement that meets the needs and preferences of all parties involved. This process can potentially lead to agreements that are more satisfactory and sustainable in the long term, benefiting both the injured party and other stakeholders.

Conclusion

In essence, Section 23 of the Civil Liability Act serves as a safeguard to promote fairness and efficiency in the resolution of personal injury claims. It underscores the importance of transparency and negotiation in the awarding of damages, particularly for substantial future losses. By notifying parties and, where applicable, the NSW Trustee & Guardian, the court fulfills its duty to facilitate informed decision-making and foster the possibility of structured settlements that prioritise the well-being and financial security of those affected by personal injury cases.

The information in this publication is of a general nature and is not intended to address the circumstances of any particular individual or entity. Although we endeavour to provide accurate and timely information, we do not guarantee that the information in this publication is accurate at the date it is received or that it will continue to be accurate in the future. We are not responsible for the information of any source to which a link is provided or reference is made and exclude all liability in connection with use of these sources. If you do not wish to receive newsletters from us, please let us know.

Latest Insights

How can the risk of litigation be reduced?

The risk of litigation can impose significant financial, reputation and operational burdens on a business.  There are an array of areas where litigation can arise including in relation to contract disputes, employment issues, regulatory breaches, consumer...

How does the court assess pain and suffering?

In New South Wales (NSW), the assessment of pain and suffering—referred to legally as non-economic loss—is governed by the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW) ("CLA"). This is compensation for the intangible effects of the injury, such as pain and suffering, loss of...

Property Disputes – How Can They Arise?

Property disputes arise in many different ways – not only in commercial contexts but also in residential settings.  Some of the types of property disputes include:...

Can a Child under 14 years commit a Crime?

In New South Wales, the age of criminal responsibility is 10 years old.  A child under 10 cannot be charged with a criminal offence. For children aged 10 to under 14, there is a legal presumption known as doli incapax, which assumes the child is incapable of...

Why is it important to know who your client is?

In a range of contexts, it is important to know who your client is. In most professional service contexts, the identity of the client is the starting point to providing advice.  If it is not clear who the professional advisor is advising, this can cause issues as...

Mental Harm Damages Following Birth Trauma: Lessons from Sorbello

In South Western Sydney Local Health District v Sorbello [2024] NSWCA 14, the New South Wales Court of Appeal has provided timely guidance on two important issues in personal injury litigation: how courts choose between competing expert opinions on mental harm, and...

Damages for Defamation – Newman v Whittington [2025] NSWSC 275

A family dispute resolution practitioner was awarded $150,000 in aggravated damages, $10,000 in interest, and an injunction in a recent Supreme Court of New South Wales case. The defendant posted defamatory statements about the plaintiff on WordPress, Facebook, and...